The Value Triangle: Why Repairs Cost What They Do


Steve Welty

Issue# 4

June 2024

Nobody enjoys overpaying for repairs. But determining what "too much" means can be tricky since value is subjective. One key concept to understand is the Value Triangle, which consists of Price, Quality, and Speed—you can only choose two. I made a brief video discussing this, which you can view here.

In a recent survey, a few clients mentioned that they feel the vendors' prices have become somewhat too high.

When we looked into it, we found that some plumbing bids were just too high. We stopped using that plumber and brought in a few with better prices. In other cases, the bids were fair for the market, but clients still thought they were too high. When this happens, it's usually because of one of three reasons:

Our Vendors Charge Too Much: It's possible that some vendors are overpriced. We strive to reduce prices where we can by always trying to use affordable vendors when this happens.
Rising Costs: Prices across the board have increased, affecting repair costs.
Poor Value Communication: There's a saying, “Value is not received until value is recognized. We need to communicate the value of our services more effectively.
Unrealistic Expectations: While DIY or cheaper handymen might seem like cost-saving options, they often lack reliability, quality, and proper licensing.

To understand these factors better, I delved into the plumbing industry, one of the most common trades in rental management 👇

General Trends

  • Labor Costs: Attracting skilled workers requires better pay. Apprentice plumbers start at $22 an hour, and journeymen earn $28-$35 an hour. Meanwhile, fast-food workers in California make at least $20 an hour. It's clear why many prefer safer, easier jobs over hazardous trades for similar pay.
  • Material Costs: Prices of essential materials like copper have soared—from $1/foot to $5/foot. Construction iron and steel prices have increased by 83%, and water heater prices have doubled since 2018, with annual increases of 8-18%.

The Home Depot Query

Clients often ask, "Home Depot charges $X for a water heater, why does your plumber charge more?" Here’s why:

  • Quality of Material: Water heaters from plumbing supply warehouses use higher quality metal components versus Home Depot's plastic parts, offering longer lifespans and better value.
  • Customer Support: Plumbing stores provide parts faster, often by the next business day, unlike Home Depot's weeks-long wait.
  • Availability: Supply houses are open 24/7 for emergencies.

Why Not Hire a Handyman?

While handymen might be cheaper, the risks are significant. Professional plumbers, who are licensed, insured, and bonded, ensure high-quality work and safety for your property.

Other Cost Drivers

  • Regulatory Changes: The strict environmental regulations in California, including those on ultra-low NOx emissions, have escalated the costs of compliant products and services.
  • Insurance Costs: California’s insurance crisis and litigious environment have led to higher premiums.
  • Fuel: Often a service call involves driving to the property to assess the situation and parts needed, then a stop to the supply house, then back to the property. According to the EIA, gas has gone up 29% since May 2021 to May 2024.

In Summary

Maintenance costs are going up because of rising material prices, labor costs, and new regulations. These changes affect the balance between cost, quality, and speed. We always look for the best vendors who provide top-notch work without breaking the bank. By sharing this information with our clients, we hope to build understanding and keep delivering high-quality service.

If you have questions about specific trades or repairs, please let me know. Your feedback helps us create valuable content and provide the best service possible.

More Goodies Below 👇


Check Out Our Tenant Screening Webinar👇

video preview

Recent Articles

How to Increase Your Tenants Rent

As a landlord, part of your job is to get the maximum ROI from your rental properties by ensuring your rental rates match the demand in your area. With inflation and the steadily increasing cost of living, landlords may consider raising their rents to cover expenses.

Read more →

The Best San Diego Neighborhoods to Invest In

San Diego is a great city to own rental property in. But which neighborhood suits your investment needs?

Read more →


Free Guides & Tools

Get your Instant Rent Estimate

Rent vs Sell Calculator

Market Update

June 2024 San Diego Market Update

Refer and Earn

We're excited to offer two months of complimentary management for each friend or family member you refer with a property in Orange County. It’s our way of saying thank you—your referrals are the highest compliment to our services!

That's it for this week! We hope you enjoyed the content and found it useful. Be sure to check your inbox next Saturday at 6 AM for our next update. Have a fantastic week!

P.S. Please share this ​newsletter​ with a friend, so they can join the conversation.

Steve Welty

CEO @ Good Life Property Management

DRE #01744610

5252 Balboa Ave #704, San Diego, California 92117
Unsubscribe · Preferences

The Housing Hero Newsletter By Steve Welty

Passionate about bringing positivity and fresh perspectives to the rental property industry CEO @ Good Life Property Management San Diego and Orange County. Managing over 1,300 units in San Diego and Orange County.

Read more from The Housing Hero Newsletter By Steve Welty

Steve Welty Issue# 43 April 2025 Happy Saturday, Housing Heroes! Checking in with some positive updates following our earlier newsletter on AB 246. I’m pleased to share that, after significant opposition from housing providers all around California, this bill has taken a turn that bodes well for us. What’s New with AB 246? Assembly Bill 246, initially introduced by Assemblyman Isaac G. Bryan, originally aimed to impose a one-year rent freeze in Los Angeles County after wildfire emergencies, a...

Steve Welty Issue# 42 April 2025 Happy Saturday, Housing Heroes! Heads up - April has brought two legislative updates for housing providers in California. We’re talking about fresh requirements for positive rent reporting and another one concerning security deposit documentation. What’s the Deal with AB 2747? Effective April 1, 2025, AB 2747 requires many housing providers to offer tenants the option to have their on-time rent payments reported to at least one credit bureau. This applies to...

Steve Welty Issue# 41 March 2025 Happy Saturday, Housing Heroes! Heads up, big news on the legislative front that could impact landlords across California. Assembly Bill 246, introduced by Assemblyman Isaac G. Bryan, is stirring up debate by proposing a statewide rent freeze for a full year. If enacted, this law would lock in rental rates at the levels charged as of January 7, 2025 and impact housing providers throughout LA County and potentially set a precedent affecting housing providers...